About Us

www.flickr.com
This is a Flickr badge showing public photos from Flickr tagged with ojaipost. Make your own badge here.


© 2006-2008 The Ojai Post
all rights reserved

The views expressed herein are the personal views of each individual author or commenter and are not intended to reflect the views of The Ojai Post or its Authors, Tribal Core or Tyler Suchman as managing editor.

Back to The Ojai Post home

Stop the Trucks: A Bridge Too Far


THE TRUCKS, THE ROCK MINES, CALTRANS, OJAI & THE SAN ANTONIO CREEK BRIDGE: OUR FUTURE HANGS IN THE BALANCE

By Michael Shapiro
Stop The Trucks! Coalition

After months of stalling, Caltrans has responded to Ojai’s request for a safety study of Route 33, finally releasing six-pages to conclude that the highway is, in fact, safe and appropriate for heavy, large-scale, industrial trucking. Taking its cue from the industry and industry lobbyists who desired that finding - without regard to the health, safety and welfare of the people here in the Ojai Valley - the Caltrans “study” is a patently outrageous travesty and a whitewash.

While taking months to produce a six-page “study” not worth the paper it’s written on, Caltrans has also been busy planning, strengthening, repairing and beefing-up various sections of both Highway 33 and Highway 150. As you may know, Highway 150 runs right past our historic, down-town Arcade, out through the East End, passing Boccali’s restaurant and continuing up the scenic-yet-treacherous Dennison Grade and on through upper Ojai to Santa Paula. It also passes by the new mega-housing development of Adams Canyon and terminates at the new Asphalt Plant being opened in Santa Paula by the giant national contractor, Granite Construction.

If I’m cynical regarding Caltrans’ ultimate objectives, it’s because there’s ample reason to be. Indeed, it doesn’t take an engineer to conclude that Route 33 can’t safely handle the huge size and weights of the behemoths now careening down there, and that our safety and welfare remain in grave jeopardy if these trucks are permitted continued access there. Yet in spite of our requests to seriously research the issue, Caltrans didn’t issue their “report” until now, effectively putting pressure on the Stop The Trucks! Coalition to challenge the findings with a more technically-sound, professional analysis, prepared in time for the next hearing scheduled before the Santa Barbara Planning Commission in Santa Maria, on July 11th.

Remember, there’s several more mining companies waiting in the wings to follow Santa Barbara’s Diamond Rock Mine getting a green light to haul down Ojai’s Route 33.

I’m also cynical regarding Caltrans having singled-out Ojai’s San Antonio Creek Bridge (on Highway 150) for retrofitting and requesting that the City of Ojai grant them jurisdiction to detour traffic around the bridge, via Gridley Road, while working to strengthen it. Could it be that the huge gravel trucks planned for Route 33 might also smell a potential windfall in new business in Santa Paula?

Surely, these trucks can just as easily take a left turn at Vons to Santa Paula as a right to Ventura. How about other trucks delivering tons of building supplies for Adams Canyon? Naturally, the companies involved in all this are claiming that they have no “intention” of moving heavy trucking through Ojai via Highway 150. However, stated “intentions” are not legally binding.

Also disturbing are recently acquired Caltrans documents obtained by Stop The Trucks! Coalition founder Howard Smith -- and only then by having to invoke the Freedom of Information Act to get them -- providing what appears to be a suspicious pattern of either delaying and/or possibly ignoring the opinion of some County planners that, in fact, Route 33 is not an appropriate, safe venue for such heavy trucks. One of the documents, written by an industry lobbyist, even goes so far as to tell Caltrans to get in step with industry material demands and that regardless of Ojai and Ventura County’s objections to massive truck traffic on Route 33, Cal Trans should recommend approval of the project if they want a regular, steady supply of road aggregate.

Unfortunately -- after reading such (previously withheld and “confidential”) documents, how can we ever trust or have faith that any Traffic and Safety Study conducted by Caltrans will be unbiased and transparent? That’s the point, we can’t. And now we know that its terribly biased. Indeed, the credibility and integrity of Caltrans, the Diamond Rock Mine, The Santa Barbara County Planners, and the industry special interests and lobbyist that promote both road building and the mining and transport of rock aggregate are now all on the line.

Don’t forget that it was Caltrans -- under their previous incarnation as the California Department of Highways -- who once wanted to build a freeway extension all the way from the 101, up the Venture River Valley, out to Ojai’s East End, eventually connecting all the way to Santa Paula’s 126 Freeway. Blocked from that development-insanity, are they now planning a more covert, less obvious method of supporting industrial-sized truck commerce via the heart and soul of the Ojai Valley?

While state law limits Ojai’s ability to control Caltrans, our city may have the legal jurisdiction -- and must now have the courage -- to reject Caltrans’ request to reroute traffic around the San Antonio Creek Bridge via Gridley Road, thus effectively blocking or at least stalling their retrofitting plans for the bridge for as long as legally possible. Did Caltrans intentionally delay the Route 33 Safety Study while completing all kinds of retrofitting, strengthening and repairing along both Route 33 and Highway 150, in an attempt at making an “end run” around Ojai’s earlier success at blocking the Freeway? Is Caltrans really being faithful to their mandate to maintain safety along California’s state roads in support of commerce? Well, they sure appear to be promoting the “commerce” part, but at Ojai’s expense:

They’re turning a blind-eye on the safety of Route 33 and Highway 150 by preparing these scenic-yet-narrow and treacherous highways for significant industrialized truck commerce. It’s a classic “Catch – 22” and, as such, Caltrans’ behavior can only be viewed as being both cynical and very troubling.


I believe that the City of Ojai has no choice but to stand-up to the monster-sized and powerful Caltrans and their industry special interest groups in the same way the Stop the Trucks! Coalition is trying to do. The City of Ojai and the Citizens of Ojai have no choice but to be in complete solidarity with each another. It’s also time for the City of Ojai to state publicly that they’re on board with sharing the legal expenses that will guide and protect us through this entire process.

Obviously, no one who loves and treasures Ojai wishes that she’d ever turn into either another polluted truck-route-of-a-town or morph into any mega-development sprawl. Sadly, hundreds of small towns scattered throughout California began their own history with more charm and healthier environments then what ultimately became of them because they lost control of their own destiny and were overtaken by unchecked, aggressive commerce and development.


I’m confident that as in many times past, our city will rise to meet this terrible and epic challenge now facing us today, and once again -- with everyone’s help and financial generosity -- we shall prevail. However, let no one doubt that Ojai is now standing at a critical crossroad, and I fear that her very survival as the town and treasure she is today, does indeed now hang in the balance.

Beautiful yet vulnerable and fragile City of Ojai… what will you do?

Comments (2)

I just returned from the meeting with Caltrans over the proposed bridge project on Ojai Avenue. I am angry about it. The city arranged the meeting and Mr. Kersnar introduced it. In his opening remarks he stated the bridge was not in the city. This is false as a citizen later pointed out. Imagine. The city manager does not know that the bridge is in the city. This is not believable.

Mike, the new public works director, I believe, also said he did not know the bridge was in the city. This is simply unbelievable and indicates a ploy on the part of the city to avoid responsibility and to once again shrug their shoulders and say they can't do anything.

Caltrans has to get a permit from the city for a bypass. The city could simply refuse to give it. Caltrans repeatedly said that they have been working with the city. They didn't say how long but it appears it has been for quite awhile. Why weren't we informed of what was in the works by the city? Someone is not telling the truth and that is what upsets me. I've seen this pattern before, especially with the O-Hi Frostie matter.

Carol Smith and Steve Olson were there but appeared to be gone about half way through the meeting. Neither one of them spoke. I told Caltrans what I think: that they are unbelievable and untrustworthy. The deal is already done and has been for a long time. Bids go out soon and once contracts are signed there is nothing that can be done. The public has been left out and we're the one paying their salaries. What do they care?

Mike, the moderator, simply ruled out any questioning of the big picture, such as the overall problem of gravel trucks going through Ojai. I made it anyway, or as much as I could.

Caltrans claims the bridge is unsafe but I don't trust them. They're probably using scare tactics to get the project through for the gravel trucks. I think the whole thing is disgraceful. Some residents spoke in favor of the project but I fear they are brainwashed by this car culture we live in.

The big bosses of Caltrans want this project and I think the city does too, although they can't admit that publicly. Many citizens spoke up about all the problems with this project but it's wasted breath except for the satisfaction of speaking one's truth. The car and money culture has most people intimidated. You can't drive in your car day in and day how and not become addicted to that lifestyle. This is just another one of the development pressures that will destroy Ojai if not resisted.

I did my part to resist it but I am just ignored as a fringe element. What do I care? I have the satisfaction of speaking up for Ojai. How many of us really believe in the values of a small town? Not many, I'm afraid. Pointing out the master plan for this whole district of strengthening and replacing bridges for the big gravel trucks is ignored because it is the truth.

The truth hurts because it threatens to seriously wound the belief we have in the superiority and necessity of our lifestyle. Some pointed out Caltrans' arrogance, disregard of the law, etc. The half dozen Caltrans employees there tonight don't want to lose their jobs, and probably don't think very deeply about these matters outside the box of their job descriptions. Their bosses make the decisions and they have to go along. The real decisions are made by the big bankers, contractors, politicians, judges and so on, and it's all about the bottom line of money, not people.

It's so hypocritical: talking about safety and not wanting to impact Ojai's economy. I want to keep Ojai safe and for us to have a vital economy, the kind of economy that contradicts everything Caltrans stands for. The city goes along for the ride. This is all a farce. I'm not going to change anybody or anything. I speak my piece and get some peace from that.

The Bridge Over San Antonio is like the Bridge Over the River Kwai: "madness, madness, madness." The madness which may very well destroy the small town values of Ojai. We may have our new bridge, thanks to Ojai and our city government and general indifference, but there won't be a town left worth living in.

This world is becoming hell on wheels. The solution is character, small town character to stand up to the Caltrans web of deceit. Sadly, such dangerous discussions are off the table as they were tonight.

Good night to all. I hope to dream of a world where we can all live in peace. Building bigger bridges invites more cars and more development. It's a nightmare, not a dream.

very interesting information, Dennis. Here is a link so that people can check out the map. Note it is a PDF.

City Map - zoom in to Ojai Ave., between Oak Glen and Boardman Road. The bridge is over the faint blue river, where there is a strange little unincorporated area that borders Ojai Ave.

Back to The Ojai Post home