Stop the Trucks: Santa Maria EIR Hearing, May 30th

Attend the hearing in Santa Maria!!!
Wednesday, May 30th at 9:00am in the "Board of Supervisors Hearing Room",
511 E.Lakeside Parkway, Santa Maria, CA 93455.
The Ojai Valley Board of Realtors is organizing a free bus ride to the meeting. The bus will be departing at 6:30 a.m. Attendants should pack a lunch and are expected to return to Ojai by 8 p.m. that night.
The Diamond Rock final EIR is now available online at:
http://www.sbcountyplanning.org/projects/03CUP-00037/index.cfm
You can access this staff report at:
http://www.sbcountyplanning.org/boards/pc/cpc_documents.cfm?DocID=1967
MORE:
Contrary to recent press stories, there is NO deal in place between Santa Barbara and Ventura Counties regarding the ban of gravel truck traffic on Route 33 from the proposed Diamond Rock Mine in the Cuyama Valley and Ojai.
This alleged deal is nothing more than an attempt to undercut our opposition. What they seek to do is an example of the classic political maneuvers of the “Three D’s:” “Delay,” “Distract” and/or “Deny.” Do not be misled!
They seek to pull attention away from their latest (and substandard) EIR of May 2007 which we will not even dignify by calling it a “Final EIR.” There are logical holes in this EIR that a blind man could drive a fleet of gravel trucks through at night.
But more dangerously, the CUP that they dangle in front of us contains no verification of truck traffic. President Franklin Delano Roosevelt once said, “Do not pass any laws you can not enforce because it only breeds disrespect for the law.”
Allowing self-monitoring of truck loads and drivers has already proven to be a disaster in Ventura County where a total failure of our own Planning Department to create CUP’s in 2001 and 2003 that have any verification or enforcement has left us with the 24/7 nightmare we now experience.
Do not be misled. There is no deal. The only way we will win this war is with your total support and dedication.
In the Ojai Valley News, Nao Braverman recently reported that, "The most recent environmental impact report for the new Diamond Rock mine claims that increased traffic from gravel trucks will not significantly impact the quality of life in Ojai... " and "... that there will be no traffic impacts if travel is not allowed during rush hour, there will be no safety impacts regarding school travel, no noise impacts, and no significant impact on air quality in Ventura County..."
"Road safety is just one of the many concerns that committee members have regarding the increasing truck traffic..."
"Michael Shapiro and Howard Smith, two active members of the local Stop the Trucks Coalition stood in front of" a packed Chaparral Auditorium on May 15. "Holding opposite ends of two pieces of rope, they stretched them out for the audience to see. One was measured to the length of two average size, modern day gravel trucks, the other was the exact width of a tunnel along Highway 33." The trucks were wider than the tunnel. “There is no way that two trucks going opposite directions could fit through that tunnel at once without hitting each other.”
Committee members are "also worried about the impact that more diesel trucks would have on the valley’s air quality, student safety, and, in turn, the local economy. Though the project’s draft EIR identifies a significant and unavoidable impact on Ojai’s quality of life, the final EIR states that the quality of life impact will be less than significant.
Committee members disagree...
Shapiro, an active participant to the citizens’ effort to keep out the proposed Weldon Canyon dump site in the early ‘90s, explained that air quality in the valley is at a much more delicate state than planners claim. Pollutants from all over the county accumulate in the valley’s basin and get trapped, he said. Though the air quality impacts from increased truck traffic would be unsuitable for any community, it is a particular concern for Ojai’s growing senior population."
“Pollutants pose a risk for everyone, but they are especially dangerous to young children and people over 60,” he said. “Highway 33 is a terribly inappropriate route for industrialization.”
"Highway 33, so named because it was constructed in 1933, was built at a time that never anticipated the weight and width of gravel trucks today, said Shapiro. The 80,000-pound trucks weighing the equivalent of between 15 and 20 sports utility vehicles each, have already taken a toll on the Arnaz Grade. The lower portion of the grade that was recently rebuilt has already begun to crack under the weight of the trucks, he said."
Rikki Horne, president of the Ojai Unified School District board, said that the despite the EIR claims, the increase truck trips would inevitably have a huge impact on local school travel.
Though the current regulations do not allow trucks to travel during the times the students generally arrive at campus and when they leave, these regulations have not been enforceable and are repeatedly disregarded, she said. Moreover Nordhoff High School, which is located alongside the highway has students coming and going at all hours of the day with some arriving as early as 6 a.m. and leaving as late as midnight. Trucks passing during school hours also interfere with the children’s outdoor education and sports practice. They pose a health and safety risk as well as noise disturbance during indoor class time, she said.
The increased truck traffic has alerted local real estate agents who foresee a huge hindrance to their sales as well as a plunge in the value of local property. Riki Strandfeldt, president of the Ojai Valley Board of Realtors said that if the proposed mine projects are approved, and truck traffic increases, the state mandates that a disclosure statement would be given to every property buyer, notifying them of the potential issue of truck traffic.
Scott Eicher, CEO of the Ojai Valley Chamber of Commerce, quoted local citrus rancher Tony Thatcher who said Ojai sits on a three-legged stool: agriculture, education and tourism. “The truck traffic could destroy all if not one of these legs,” he said. “Our avocado and citrus crops will be destroyed by the pollution, no one is going to want to pay money to bring their children to schools if they can’t enjoy the outdoor beauty of the valley because it’s so polluted, and no one is going to want to visit if they can’t see the mountains because the air is brown.”
Though the EIR for the Diamond Rock Mine included a condition that recommends a ban on trucks traveling from the mine through the Ojai Valley, the project could still be approved without granting that condition. The deal is also contingent on Ventura County officials banning Ventura gravel trucks from traveling through Santa Barbara County.
“I think that because of the recommendation, some people in the community might have gotten the impression that the community can relax,” said 1st District Supervisor Steve Bennett. “That would be a mistake, The community needs to keep itself organized and keep raising funds. This EIR alone needs some good analysis by experts. People should not be complacent at this critical time.
The committee, currently deciding on environmental consultants and attorneys, is looking at a war chest budget of $50,000 to $100,000 or more. “We are going to need a great deal of economic support from people in the community,” said Shapiro.


Comments (4)
If one knows that the 1933-era tunnels are not large enough to measure up to the minimum dimensions required for reasonably safe use and nevertheless maintains that they are safe, the only logical conclusion to be drawn from their behavior is that, despite whatever claims they might make to the contrary, they are simply not concerned with our lives. Caltrans it seems, is capable of accurately measuring the tunnels and of determining the measurements of the vehicles expected to pass through them. Therefore, if Caltrans states that Highway 33 is safe, we can reasonably deduce that that agency has been bought and/or pressured in order to cause them to misrepresent the facts.
Just say "know".
Comment #1 Posted by: Joseph Gilbert | May 24, 2007 05:59 PM
How would we obtain info re: how Diamond,et al, have authority and/or rights to mine these products from Calif.lands( washes,river beds,etc.)? and: what is the issuing state(?)agency for those rights and how is the State (or?) compensated (fees)??
Comment #2 Posted by: Stephen H. | May 27, 2007 08:58 PM
Stephen,
Though they are long and tedious, the EIR and the other documents noted in our links, will give you most of the information you need.
The coalition has brought top notch legal and enviornmental experts on board to help with this ongoing fight.
We are currently up against two different mines in two different counties and there are more out there waiting to see what happens.
Your contributions are all that stands between us and a flood of trucks.
Comment #3 Posted by: hjs | May 28, 2007 10:05 AM
I commute each morning between Ojai and Ventura via Santa Ana Road and this week each morning there have been double trucks heading into Ojai on Santa Ana. Monday there were 8 trucks in the the 7 minutes between the Corner Market and Foster Park, Tuesday 4 trucks, today 3. All at different times, but all within commute time. These trucks are trying to circumvent Highway 33, but they are taking an even more hazardous route, both to residents on Santa Ana, commuters (two narrow bridges) and bicyclists. They must be stopped. I've reported this to Steve Bennett's office and they feel this is quite inappropriate. Let's keep the pressure on these truckers.
Comment #4 Posted by: Jenny Phelps | June 6, 2007 11:26 AM